Which would you choose? Location is not an issue. They are literally next door to each other in the complex.
One is cheaper and smaller. 2 bedroom, 2 bath. 1143 square feet. New appliances. Good carpets. I would not have to do ANYTHING to get it ready for me. However, no cat room and less space. Plenty of extra money for new furniture.
One is more expensive and bigger. 3 bedroom, 2 bath. 1324 square feet. OK carpets but I hate the color of the kitchen. To move in, I would have to add mirrors to the livingroom and paint the kitchen. Small stuff, really. Bigger place. Dedicated cat room. Better resale value. Less money for new furniture.